The piece is absolutely stunning. I especially like the blank, yet sly smile expression on the girl's face which symbolizes to me a thoughtful mood. The background outline's the figure very effectively, the line art is consitant and well shaped. Great shading on the eyes. Another thing that really sets the piece for me is the two flowers set upon her collar and in her hair, I feel like they bring your attention to the great detail made upon shading and line-art. One thing I would say to improve though is the shading around her breast area, apart from that, a very meaningful, beautiful piece. Brilliant work, keep it up.
I would like to state first is that this is my first critique. So please bare with me and I do hope what I am saying is accurate and does make sense. Second, I shall be basing your image off of this one: [link] but at the same time giving off my personal opinions as well. I'll try not to be too harsh when it comes to comparisons. Ready? Lets begin.
I really like the background as it makes the character "pop" out to the viewer. Also, I like how you drew the flowers. Very nice and seems very accurate to me, comparing with the actual image. The "lighting" seems well done as the shadows does give the image a 3-dimensional feeling. In addition to that, the shadows are well put in considering the type of background you provided. So not too much and not too little; just right.
Now time for the blunt and brutal but helpful part of the critique. The chin seems very disfigured to me. It should be a lot sharper and smoother. The body needs a little more work. Comparing with the actual image, she needs to be skinnier. As for her hair, it seems flat, as in, it doesn't seem natural. I would advise you to try to make her hair more smoother and give it more of a flow. The hair just seems to be hanging or dangling there. So again, the hair needs to look more "flowy" (not sure if that's a word lol). And finally, and be warned that this will seem very brutal but, I would consider using guidelines, especially for the anatomy. I know guidelines are annoying and most people would just want to get right into the drawing. But without it, there won't be much consistency when it comes to future works. Again, sorry if that sounded brutal but I have to be honest, especially on a critique. If you ARE using guidelines, then I would advise you to practice on using guidelines as often as you can. I can assure you that with better guidelines it WILL benefit you in the later future.
Overall, this is a beautiful masterpiece, a very well attempted one. You really have a lot of potential and I encourage you to keep working on what you are doing. Sorry if the guideline part sounded brutal but, like my professors have told me, I would never cheat you when it comes to making you better. That's what's important. Anyways, nice work!
Jordan
I really like the background as it makes the character "pop" out to the viewer. Also, I like how you drew the flowers. Very nice and seems very accurate to me, comparing with the actual image. The "lighting" seems well done as the shadows does give the image a 3-dimensional feeling. In addition to that, the shadows are well put in considering the type of background you provided. So not too much and not too little; just right.
Now time for the blunt and brutal but helpful part of the critique. The chin seems very disfigured to me. It should be a lot sharper and smoother. The body needs a little more work. Comparing with the actual image, she needs to be skinnier. As for her hair, it seems flat, as in, it doesn't seem natural. I would advise you to try to make her hair more smoother and give it more of a flow. The hair just seems to be hanging or dangling there. So again, the hair needs to look more "flowy" (not sure if that's a word lol). And finally, and be warned that this will seem very brutal but, I would consider using guidelines, especially for the anatomy. I know guidelines are annoying and most people would just want to get right into the drawing. But without it, there won't be much consistency when it comes to future works. Again, sorry if that sounded brutal but I have to be honest, especially on a critique. If you ARE using guidelines, then I would advise you to practice on using guidelines as often as you can. I can assure you that with better guidelines it WILL benefit you in the later future.
Overall, this is a beautiful masterpiece, a very well attempted one. You really have a lot of potential and I encourage you to keep working on what you are doing. Sorry if the guideline part sounded brutal but, like my professors have told me, I would never cheat you when it comes to making you better. That's what's important. Anyways, nice work!
The Artist has requested Critique on this Artwork
Please sign up or login to post a critique.